Progressive vs Allstate.
Head-to-head on price for the 25-55 driver, Full coverage, Good credit bracket, across every city where we have filed data for both.
Progressive
$211.77/mo avg
Cheaper in 50 of 57 shared cities
Allstate
$256.49/mo avg
Cheaper in 7 of 57 shared cities
CityProgressiveAllstate
Albuquerque, NM
$270.00
$276.00
Anchorage, AK
...
$172.53
Annapolis, MD
$211.00
...
Atlanta, GA
$260.83
...
Aurora, IL
$123.00
$229.08
Austin, TX
$247.00
...
Baltimore, MD
$259.00
...
Bangor, ME
$129.00
...
Baton Rouge, LA
$327.00
...
Billings, MT
$231.42
$290.08
Birmingham, AL
$229.83
$177.33
Bismarck, ND
$180.00
...
Boise, ID
...
$140.00
Boston, MA
$154.00
...
Bridgeport, CT
$319.58
$350.58
Buffalo, NY
$103.08
$255.08
Burlington, VT
$128.00
...
Casper, WY
$131.00
...
Cedar Rapids, IA
$149.08
$240.83
Charleston, SC
$224.08
$245.50
Charleston, WV
$179.00
...
Charleston, WV
$217.58
$303.25
Charlotte, NC
$135.00
$393.00
Cheyenne, WY
...
$263.67
Chicago, IL
$169.50
...
Cleveland, OH
$148.00
...
Colorado Springs, CO
$261.75
$353.58
Columbia, SC
$219.75
$226.42
Columbus, OH
$148.00
...
Denver, CO
$220.92
$325.33
Des Moines, IA
$175.67
$242.17
Detroit, MI
$437.00
...
Dover, DE
$210.00
$380.00
Eugene, OR
$199.00
...
Fairbanks, AK
$163.67
$190.00
Fargo, ND
...
$103.00
Fayetteville, AR
$278.75
$275.00
Fort Wayne, IN
$115.75
$208.33
Grand Rapids, MI
$225.08
...
Gulfport, MS
$233.33
$258.67
Hartford, CT
$314.83
$337.00
Hilo, HI
$151.00
...
Honolulu, HI
$123.67
$167.50
Houston, TX
$239.33
$287.08
Huntington, WV
$132.00
$155.00
Idaho Falls, ID
$148.00
...
Indianapolis, IN
$140.00
$234.83
Jackson, MS
$153.00
$144.00
Jersey City, NJ
$303.75
$388.50
Kansas City, MO
$221.00
...
Las Vegas, NV
$335.00
...
Lexington, KY
$117.00
$164.00
Lincoln, NE
$193.17
$206.08
Little Rock, AR
$225.00
...
Los Angeles, CA
$187.40
...
Louisville, KY
$312.17
$389.58
Madison, WI
...
$235.25
Manchester, NH
$169.50
$172.67
Memphis, TN
$176.00
...
Miami, FL
$311.00
...
Milwaukee, WI
...
$290.00
Minneapolis, MN
...
$221.75
Missoula, MT
$195.92
$267.33
Montgomery, AL
$208.25
$205.58
Montpelier, VT
$128.00
...
Naperville, IL
$124.00
$143.00
Nashua, NH
$153.75
$170.25
Nashville, TN
$175.58
...
New Orleans, LA
$597.67
...
New York City, NY
$231.90
...
Newark, NJ
$383.92
$401.17
Oklahoma City, OK
$190.00
$347.00
Omaha, NE
$215.08
$232.17
Orlando, FL
$311.00
...
Overland Park, KS
$158.83
$264.08
Philadelphia, PA
$198.00
...
Phoenix, AZ
$265.67
...
Pittsburgh, PA
$239.92
$223.00
Portland, ME
$125.08
$153.75
Portland, OR
$383.25
...
Providence, RI
$251.25
$365.50
Provo, UT
$148.00
$146.00
Raleigh, NC
$116.00
$377.00
Rapid City, SD
$221.92
$245.08
Reno, NV
$274.42
$298.08
Richmond, VA
$184.00
...
Saint Paul, MN
...
$197.00
Salt Lake City, UT
$193.42
$321.33
San Diego, CA
$123.58
...
Santa Fe, NM
$97.00
$146.00
Savannah, GA
$164.25
$214.17
Seattle, WA
$155.08
...
Sioux Falls, SD
$130.25
$191.08
Spokane, WA
$196.50
$207.67
St. Louis, MO
$291.17
$356.33
Tucson, AZ
$266.67
$238.08
Tulsa, OK
$184.00
$316.00
Virginia Beach, VA
$186.00
$214.00
Warwick, RI
$203.17
$271.42
Washington, DC
$362.00
$402.00
Wichita, KS
$225.00
...
Wilmington, DE
$243.50
$465.17
Worcester, MA
$247.42
...
About this comparison
Prices come from the same filed or state-average data used across the rest of Open Rate Index. A city only counts toward the "cheaper in" tally when we have a price for both insurers there.