Cheapest car insurance in Madison, Wisconsin

Wisconsin requires minimum liability coverage of 25/50/10, plus uninsured motorist coverage. Rates below are monthly estimates for the 25-55 driver, Full coverage, Good credit bracket.

Filed per-carrier data
Methodology → All of Wisconsin →

Pulled directly from carrier rate filings for this city.

With 269,840 residents, Madison sits in the mid-size band where carriers file rates regularly but the field of insurers is a bit shorter than in a major metro. The spread here is wide, 62% between the cheapest and priciest insurer we track, which is exactly the kind of gap a flat citywide average would hide. On average, drivers here pay about 16% less than the national baseline we track.

What do you pay now?
#InsurerPosition in spreadMonthly
01 GEICOFiled rate $93.92
02 Erie InsuranceFiled rate $133.00
03 NationwideFiled rate $137.83
04 Rural Mutual InsuranceFiled rate $145.42
05 Auto-OwnersFiled rate $165.42
06 West Bend Insurance CompanyFiled rate $202.50
07 FarmersFiled rate $225.08
08 AllstateFiled rate $235.25
09 Acuity InsuranceFiled rate $249.83
Switch & save
See what switching insurers actually saves

Rate explainer
Why is your best rate $93.92 and not $209.31?

Madison is priced against 9 insurers for the 25-55 driver, Full coverage, Good credit bracket. Below is every step from the national baseline to your best filed rate.

City vs national baseline, adult/full $-32.84
Age bracket, 25-55 +$0.00
Coverage, Full coverage +$0.00
Credit tier, Good (modeled) +$0.00
Driving record, Clean (modeled) +$0.00
What if
What would change your rate here?

Based on the modeled credit/record adjustment on top of this city's filed 25-55 driver, Full coverage, Good credit base rate. Not a quote.

About these numbers

Rows marked filed come from a per-carrier, per-city import. Rows marked state-average estimate are built by spreading a statewide average across insurers until real per-city data is imported. Credit tier and driving record are always modeled adjustments, never filed. Your real premium depends on your record, exact address and chosen limits.